Slots for rests

Discussions, advice, bug reports and much more about the "bach" environment.
Post Reply
alroli
Posts: 10
Joined: Fri Aug 18, 2017 3:57 pm

Slots for rests

Post by alroli » Fri Aug 16, 2019 12:12 pm

Hi, I have a question about slots in rests: It seems that the slot information disappears once I do a dump, so the stored information for that rest slot is not available, is that the case?. For example, In the Notation Help Center's page "Slots for rests in separate syntax", if I connect a [bach.print] to the extras [bach.score] outlet and I do a dump, I'm getting:

bach.print: [ breakpoints [ [ [ [ ] ] [ ] ] ] ] [ slots [ [ [ [ [ 10 ferm ] ] ] [ ] ] ] ]

Shouldn't I get something like the following?:

[ breakpoints [ [ [ [ ] ] [ ] ] ] ] [ slots [ [ [ [ [ 10 ferm ] ] ] [ 10 ferm] ] ] ]

I'm not sure to understand the point of assigning a slot to a rest (chord) if I can't retrieve it later, probably I'm missing something here, please could you clarify?

Code: Select all

<pre><code>
----------begin_max5_patcher----------
1829.3oc6bssjahCD8YOeET7TRUSlEItuukJ+B6aS4xkLHaqDPhBDykMU92W
cAaKrEyXa7LI0r3j.1RB0pOp6iTCz4m2LycI6Ibiqye6buyrY+7lYyTEIKXV
2um4VhdJq.0nZlKE+Ha42cuUWEG+DWU7RT1l6ppIT91pnskrVdAlqtNutRqP
7rMD55E03LtVtvD+67t0Iv2SdJBHOBg244LeeOQna6HPWgjbkbEikuDsUjMn
Gv4KDEI56EHNulrrkqUuY6TmYtOfqaHLpnaWhqkUl344Eop7W2by1i+5laOQ
HoD2zfViOBSxaKqriFaUBcQ7mqvZnv0cmRaAn7CkPC.jJO4m9x3D7XbJv8BT
tLVYId+r5Nk6e1PZbxwqHTbiCx4aANHZt3K03lcMtPTYFqkxMGPqXTdC4eUZ
LPNy+RlKxFSQkpF690ZBpXaeurc4xBrIXZAw.9JqIPR5cIdw9BSrtO9hBCU0
E3cFVZfnqID90lFxZpXD6zTv3NblB7b9T1FVc9msBh9+F.wPPjxTKAJOkpNF
FbNnVvaKpQY7cNemEvnU+FRN9PrcDvELVQm4CStKbmUFL7LvqjKAtTDv7Zrc
j.N.RD1UpcJwAYots++Vhnq2ybML9YiSyS6gFawCEBiUXmm+cfTXTXTZ2m3c
xRLzzqJI9Xp3qPYXyY5WCxgau3G2vJvKj33hbDGsva2mNc+doBKs7Zje49AN
.Dia2U35RYAy6e3jZT2gcJ5giqcLBBRNm4WS2q7bkikfTuwQTXs3zmZvUnZD
G6z7Lkid5yWAuM3UhgW3lIfwjXoyFDFc9T5WjyVKmynm4Z688RrnKo.CUwSa
5eFZBzaueVs.Q435EXJpCC8thar496u+aAycte974mEayIrsmyh7HRsGHPZx
wbGu11Hsr8HP3Ey61jwpeMh2JhX7iyIBOJ55sJNssnv0bDZfVoWEt4WlqNiQ
aDCHw11WhQkMDZSkf4rua6iBpBA3SVRJH7mkUEmB7tj4KEZ3.06iEFqX2AAI
FyQELVkAQKP8WOSlSyh1eYD5OxeVLNHYMblj9xTCdfQD5jPwHRUW14ZmqHCA
K1IKpsfK2Jglb217SCGsZkb+XcUGZccnWasH0vQhYMlKobf1T7bcOcIduIhV
cL8m5YYGa3slwJX0Fp79C.Cc2vGHt+5fJ65AVHryl2XEQBcEyXZRWgx3PbFU
VILeZywNX5C3BVEt+BhJSX45gszLNQRtZV6OvO6dfgfq1OR7kEO08Gou3hUE
LDOJXWg5qy6DaGvS3cAhRRi5IqlsC3SUVFCSbkXa8hkZQGqVqqEXeuRdtghp
5WTNqT3fd8UzXXTpOLHwhvFg5xwkUrZTQIKGqU+Bgh+vAy1BaSLM+nozGI47
MpgQasE3ZClrdCWYM0xY8qSvcstP46thUyI3bkqbmk39lkwpd9wMXAOmvZ7H
4ixDdVM5gMJWDP6i0DN93suAOz5VEJhcS2+XLrsNeOYXOYXazPeqF1hsGTPZ
31sqsV4GT95tcI3d5lhIoIAwdAunkDkQOSqnST3ogwAgvj2ZSMvEYpEXmCUp
KCarMP0ePYQOSyMuIqrirxBGhPaPxrIhrIhryxDKZXhrWfDah.ah.6TrthOz
5RemAraYotCcupg0GMf8x1paxg.6JRA9E14g0Z+cBuIdPfe3ATx+wX2ldH7J
E1FwkXGdsW6o.uWVbXeDrfUO+n92jMgLyZKTLwCPQ7BMYhqXPjFXcMd.XHi4
CAo+O.sWFOAv98RC.mf1QCs1uaN.+InczPq86dAHXBZGMzZOjcP3DzNZn0dn
pfnInczParcnMdBZGMzlXGZSlf1QCso1g1zIncrPKzyJzJeIslf1Q9z2sGMF
bJZrwCs1iFCNEM13IDrGMFbJZrwCs1iFCNEM13gV6QiAmhFa7Pq8nwfSQiMd
n0dzXvonwFOzZOZL3TzXiGZsGMFbJZrQCs91iFyeJZrQAsl8UYonMMG+9+y3
XyyFWhLMW68EyWpD8SZe64AmHr7JY+NIP+2aAF7dKvv2SAtu1RT8Ov0G7roK
I4jrMHJEWbrgr4yzdaRnru1suZAGWS+CAZHde0GLtJvOfK5XH5KeveA288uE
ndx7cuMSGmsn1S5SuCNquvuX1wWPu3YKGRMxomQmDoClff5LH8d4GwX0QNRc
lOetnjteMe9PIOn+6TxCB7TYiFvOzRlG6o+eWA+yH8ASMydP0U4ZjpXawS0.
QVdeTsg0VmsUg5RDKmHirSqgSn5Wvt8sQFnf2.yampbBz8wKJm3qfbROQ4rW
mE7I5zcD7lKXXu1rSvdiRvp6z6qI4zeaRN1tjgu8RV8jb8t1yyGzqCqzvdVx
ZGUTUUWV1pjhTFBhtuqycxjaU+jP0+TwNIVT6Ax11qa.pVvvvEzKs0ZBnmhB
b0WpX+g0zVRmRJzNgHUjnpr.spK+PUbs27qa9O7zY8dE
-----------end_max5_patcher-----------
</code></pre>

danieleghisi
Site Admin
Posts: 1347
Joined: Fri Dec 03, 2010 1:25 pm

Re: Slots for rests

Post by danieleghisi » Sat Aug 17, 2019 9:31 pm

Yes you should. I confirm that I can reproduce the issue, I'll try to fix it for the next release.
Thanks for pointing this out.

d

alroli
Posts: 10
Joined: Fri Aug 18, 2017 3:57 pm

Re: Slots for rests

Post by alroli » Sun Aug 18, 2019 9:45 am

Oh, I thought that I was doing something wrong, I didn't even thought that it could be a bug (I'd have attached Bach version and so on, sorry for that).

Anyway, great to know that this time my code is not the culprit! ;D

danieleghisi
Site Admin
Posts: 1347
Joined: Fri Dec 03, 2010 1:25 pm

Re: Slots for rests

Post by danieleghisi » Mon Aug 19, 2019 9:49 am

Yes, unfortunately that happens more often than I would like :-)
That was a bug, I have fixed it for next release (since you are a Patron, you'll get access to a prerelease containing the fix quite soon!)

Best,
Daniele

Post Reply