Missing starting chord in chord interpolation?

Discussions, advice, bug reports and much more about the "bach" environment.
Post Reply
fiboribo
Posts: 21
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2016 6:17 pm

Missing starting chord in chord interpolation?

Post by fiboribo » Fri Dec 22, 2017 6:19 pm

Hello,

Is there a reason that the highest pitch of the first chord is not included in the first chord of the resulting list? It's easy enough to prepend the chord or simply add the note afterwards but it seems that it shouldn't be missing.

Thanks!

Federico

<pre><code>
----------begin_max5_patcher----------
6426.3oc6cs0jihir94t+UP3mlYi53V2kXeZOub1eDSrQET1TUwL1fCLtuLa
r+2O5BFCXrKgMfomMcGcYaItjYpTojv56K+2e9SKdI66w6WD72C9sfO8o+8m
+zmrEYJ3Ske+SK1F88Uah1aOrEoweK6keewStpJh+dgs3WhV89xh2SROVy9h
erI1V0wRROrMIcSbg85PNUX1ghikRKKcWTwJ805smyiWU3jNLWtjpeQTOEvY
nkH8agl+RHKQA+qxSzcsJ9wtX2You4k+u5PRVakJsR7+PWXJ5+74Oa9ySCfA
H9O2lrNY2lne3oYf1oYfbEy.hxVxjBbn3o.kJzZSvzmBBk9YLRRK5zVDJuEi
w1386idK9LqQOLAc6IfuhIPpVpJ8DDLwRg9kR9T.k5gEnSUWbKp9prsai0Fy
1p9p2yxWGP7T6wcp8nKq8LNZoRqwggZMNDUo8bmgPvzl.TMSPc8jM75IdrzS
BmtDq0Gtn+5IcH0yruFmGsIX+pnMwikxpHbaGYoVqvLlUCkjmBzd5nqnm3aQ
Oe4PQQV5coIWoyIOjXkdhtYCyqTDBypHrq027knz25r+oRNfwo2M.sjdp+5d
pHyKcbJV3MFaRgVT+lEmWpwkp7mV7ZxlXsG59Dca5IQ6SKh1sqVwep1oXrS+
dl8BIeppnjTWQzphxi+ZR6Kq95lqU4Bs9dH2Y29tRr3zkIacbd5gD643JT2h
84iWvSVIi4.irdEB2n4LUM2bci6aaxV8Gwqq0yQay1EmljtKOdutmZTQovUU
853WiNro34WyRK1m7mV4Cqs4cU+qQqhu3ImFs0ob+u4IQaNpdKdKOYcVpQHZ
XpMEe71YlnhU230UF6QjFsqiSV2HqMKWnx8Zk7v9WhxMsDu3bTIGqrHKaSyp
pNuMwuVTV8tjzzVVwhrcWtx7j2d+Jm6KY5J2dsqssl8OeH0U6y5NjEOuO5qM
s1EQa1T1Cs4k+6QoIaiJhKRbMADTUkwoQZE888qxy1rog95p4qcTyZsS7p3u
krt3c6Mptyf9vS1czIZQUq75j2h2Wzrrhn212rjyBbnK5vKkcRetHdqdJPEs
NfFS1tdOx5wxZT9UmtUy.aqOrcW8JNW.uzTutbDtKEkipVRTboYdmBaeXFtc
7sOHFW63bjEGK1FluLvwMZlZD5uioo+JY6poxTwsA2nR6aBwcZlXhozN8s7n
cUyvyWKE99rTLj0URd2VpoxipH30fWFLaDwGaDQZWrG0yNcutIKpvr1uFyv5
LCFdHMXWKREF+ErHf9EV.lZ9j7Kp.rdYclOGp+L2TCV+A5WHlCQoOBV.wbDJ
8AvzG.wb.r.poZltZR.yTMSWMIfapjDHLURBjAJSUjfP8DNz0TWj1jjFuJ6P
ZQaS+XFQ.iH1nmH8TDIJ6L74X6aT9s6tilx.C+sIN5IyMHC+NiIPUS5nLahJ
l1XmDrMpI+dicRoSocZ6JxqA+CszETLstUDlzsLj61uZPGqwZTrSjskIaU1F
2Zz9M67Xq8GbKQeWhYZnqSJx0Q7OJ9oGLyMtkF5Zgbupe+5ZIRlx+Zld5zlk
GUNO1E+hYfkes408Bq+xd9t0jpasdwsVVYHBco1WQC2gnWe0Dut7FyabGWoW
wyQI5+qovzzwP0VW1uKZUhYXwJyJV1xZpuBtCssm0lrrcMaOZ1Jb0INiQtoD
Z+aHo7gcclcr6khd8m0cG++pC8SaLn32dOaS7yFGvmWGUD8Lp5U48w4aV1zu
eSVQR5qYGK.erBqfqeORuRnjhCqiChS+Z7F8ZbcdLGONqBne+0CoqrKFqQs+
Q7OzugZTlyoV+gm+d4+LcYd1NMGAqpP24g773vHEBgEJyyUu18Z+QA126UMw
LtwCpnQc+vrf+pu8qMqbc11njzgWAkDQHkvTcbytC0zs1ZSCodMuY4QaZpLu
GadfBVGgCEYmqsj19KFGpftcFlMtJcZIAWkQ1Ug1oqRRZwlj8Ec6ozYk+EMl
R4Cvbg+MxpPEShXc2F440HjKYbhpWMjrt6yatEWto7BU+Wzd88rwDM4sg7K0
Y7hcDgNgypNghK2I7Jc.gNeygNex1sca9Qdxp8c2tYWs8G1rMEhspsXa9wKu
RD+Nqc.DdEhfo7V849HgO7r9K6tTOkyqYJ6nHvHLlflhNJ24D5vnNiAgQcaV
SyRimGNxXb2BNd1K3cubKLY1K3cO4eLc1K3cOYWLa1K3cOCOLe1K3cOyFrX1
K3xtEb4rWvUcK3pYufG1sfGN2EbR2ibRl8ibR5djSxrejSR2ibRl8ibR5djS
xrejSR2ibRl8ibR5djSxrejSR2ibRl8ibR5djSxrejSR2ibRl8ibR5djSxre
jSZ2ibRm0ibd5nLnTHJc89y+4VyJhq+dsSw.TiFen9h6cOdkiueQ0rieutI5
FRm5aHapug7o7Fdp12xyNrq0yLbaT9eDm2tvj0IqdOJMMdy9RWtSU9Kd41K3
bJy45KUHVXn2mo6A1wBwgJCPJ7sGljf4DJwtMKNYBZ9disCQ6c8P01B72BvA
+qAb68X2dK8biNgFfMpM1smQQG+602qSWc+hvCqKoGANkUCFPCkSlFrcPGxq
ceLmeEqTMSf.0GSvIjfTaGL01pXEJS8caa1mcHe0wlmisBAMEv05P.IoU.i4
2Nt25aebumrdcbZaqx5j8FXT3.zgWMj8UjYBOEY1LRlIdJyFWh4hLaVNM1G6
ruxrdLfcYIoEk9tR7RtoChEGWg3kBlNLCsqRJ2q5XLdo73ldV1dG1MQVDeZE
op4SqHpOxLdVHycX9tfmmX1XmoTesyymnRTeiJ0gi+CSlMhBwG6Lc1Hy9Zlo
CkYtbtlGQM6BCxIW+rCknOGUTjm7xgB2THpCC3dglw21j8RzlRrJVsAiuFzF
Og+wOeRdGHth3WPFPd9qiEcQHHgKIFHYalCL0AjjaFM13gjjL9kQUsU7k7vv
PonRso2rZSFP.3WD7h9eapvL2sAAelePvOjXADCxLakqq31E77zo2OaSy2vf
bSLLQafc3OnN7.PGK1+d121WDusAWSzMBOrGazpUIqMaqiM62kG+ZbdbZIDG
NRJMcfAjOD+GW.6GWC2GK95elks0TVHt536BGHWFCHMw+w+7jzzI3O7A3GcB
5iq.3iOjKLT0nuHmWIlgrEwXUWjhrTci7IZWfUyn1IPPtCPfXcBVeH2NRVCm
l5N5ri2H.UHvV8GPEBfJD.UHvFRGPEBrwzATg.nBAPEBfJD.UH.pP.Tg.nBA
PEBfJD.UH.pP.Tg.nBAPEBfJD.UH.pP.Tg.nBAPEBfJD.UH.pPtxSUxuClyI
1MRARw3JoPQ5wC1SPnXD6BfAoW.Qo5R4KvWXTAyI0BAqOPXYHkZrPhEJ+s0D
BCwcRsjxk7GiTatP17+i2dHXyP9FoVgvLl3wH0RBhzColvIHbMPNIeHRMESB
U8PpoDAqzuNT6hv3OFolxCsn7xWoVFF5r0bDgQPgOFolKXndH0BTHg3jZLVJ
PnGiTqi4p5gTeJds1AmfdPwqoZuSQe7PHXUoslH0ZL6gH0LrTw5gTa9kcJkZ
Jlh4OF+ZFEwYHUO7qozxdiTl1sl9XjZFRp5gTy3TQnSp0CRhUOHoliMcp72C
Q2IfVJ0TBh+X5MxDXhnORsJLrLFBiKoOpdiRLG0G+ZJgT5gvQ5NDOl30LEV1
mdiDo.W5gvYZU.+Xj5Jfd2630bsJ+f7PzylfzqdimhWKHH5CJdsd5xLQOiWW
dlBtNHxiIxmdZERzsEuVhIzGT7ZNEQjJ1sDuVRCIOn30bJmF1Go9T7ZoPuL8
GTuQ63xraIdsR2y7AEuVOBmf1CotV7ZS6zCJdsdDNIuGRcs30pPcHyGjGhdv
hd0aDai1YNyPhj+nhWqWHXe5MVKdcnPOQjGTjOg.2mdil30J6YJP3P9iJdsc
rhaIds1RqC88fhWKETdOiWyKkZIV9n5MpvL4MEu15Y8nhWqD7vaJds.qs1CW
75ljYjGDYzvfi2143tAOUZK4hp7jHkorPoz7DJOO814KLl4CHLlWE8V7xc4Y
lsi7RGXrtjYnAjXocCw0diuaLuFfRwXalF29zTXNyCsl4oOvGsKCGgcKFNCY
EbH4xlES81Bb3+cP7YBsdIhpjJNtLS+0emE4Plz40crW6.V93zUgDxKyhbUY
TNOP6dmpsXHY3fUahixGKFNfvb4QUSjTA1kkku0Faz.1XuKv9ywRFqFapxwn
RD6a7aUmEUBXIQfzlRQLQ1JgseiTpdztc0JtACpnsO+tiMCjOUUTRpqHZUQ4
wmf3dEgssHJWqoEZ07Ptyb8ckXwoKS1537Tc7Dy474OUmiTLWvSXt2kROsDd
QYP.8LDpw2TKd4sMYq9iV4s9rcwoIoMvzP8pKw9yyWHyV1n91oMyFU1c5bbw
a4IqyRMBQCSso3i2NSHeWHs5Ji8Hzi9zwI63LlKT4dsRdX+KQ4lVhWb9mjJ1
dIKaSyppNuMwuVTV8tjzzVVwhrcWtxbyNY4xU+RltxsW6ZaqY+yGRc09rtiX
wyF9wo4wEsYSYOylW9uGklrMpHtHw0DPpR7nKhSMbxy66WYIwf55qqlu1QMq
0Nwqhc6wGyMptyPO3hmSLqyUnem8GdorS5yFL0nmzUqCPqcWhVAu+7085Ca2
MUYl2ZDVovwUO36L47Rlzb9LY6poN2X6Fz+dy4yLwTZm9Vdzt.7zlcroRybu
Cj2skZp7nJBdshkjteaDwqThsisFod1oqB7uWktXY3gzfcsHU3.4WHAr.r7K
r.9T0QDiHUKTknTFSmhcuNYnor63eahiY4xS8r6NuqqlzX6mdVGSTDKhyNwu
2HVT5TZm1th7Zv+PKcAESqaEg4VXD5t8qFzH7so8s9Q8adR+aWgs2tDWt4Ee
tcENc6i30sKxiaWmK2NmO2ZJLcRoa9RqaWjZ29.5cyG9UGgN8zWBIKw1GW4Y
1wtW.38Qkam4+1XlU.ysAzwEvba.ysAL2FPZT.ysAjGEvba.ysAL2Fvba.ys
AL2Fvba.ysAL2Fvba.ysAL2Fvba.ysAL2Fvba.ysAL2Fvba.ysAL2Fvba.ys
AL2VmPviyoLmquTgXgg2LMO3YOLIAysL8jGPfySXvMPauG61aomazIz.r8nw
xqjo5uNfeZueQLYRd+Sl82pgxISC1NnC4yVBiw4WwJUGMLn9XBNg+hZ6fo6M
UCaZE7JWCOexB0cjDuuPVndFIy9lRmEn4iLiOKAueA6ruxrdLfcYIoEk9tRr
IC4RQVzSEhWJX5vLztJobGhiw3kxi64YY6cX2DYQ7JwbqlOshn9Hy34QNaW4
aObw7IOyS80NOehJQ8MpDCOejYinP7wNSmMxrulY5PYlKmq4QrptvfWw0O6v
l4yFHvm7xgB2THpC91dggv21j8RzlRDBVsAiuFfBOg5vOeRdGpzZOJXLSr8L
rXo95iL+zmDGjXY2ZhsWPGRzt+KipZKYKElMssnRso2rZyFP3tWD7h9eapPp
1sg2c1Gi2cG78zyqm6E6F7zo2OO2mW2XbSrBRaPc3OfN7.LG1Ty99h3sMRK6
citC6wFsZUxZyV5Xy9c4wuFmGmVBuAZMJ.oE9O9PrebAbebMLeTxkG5xBwcS
zIhJujKf+ilX+3edRZ5D3G9.5iNA7wU.6wUbBOBwHgCJ9LrkuQjUCBtnHKU2
zdhdCX2.Er3KrOrM8qOjaG6pgqRc2a0hKPLP.NPfM2OfCD.GH.NPfsfNfCDX
qnC3.AvABz4CvABfCD.GH.NP.bf.3.AvABfCD.GH.NP.bf.3.AvABfCD.GH.
NP.bf.3.AvABfCD.GH0dpR+LkoyqtT+Tk0KwBIVn72VOOx5klKjnGYU94QVu
jHIHROj5QK+Q9fxrWkIvF7Xk.avgnAIA1fgDXCj.afDXCj.alSIvFcW0i4BB
AcPRfMTHA1.IvFHA17eGIvF7Wvh.df9cRfHPFndfIwl6OQZ.YwFHK1.YwFHK
1.YwlYcVro1bVgrXCfdI.RJ.5k.WE.8R.5k.zKAnWB5DBnWB57AnWBPuDfdI
.8R.5k.zKAnWBPuDfdI.8R.5k.zKAnWBPuDfdI.8R.5k.zKAnWBPuzOcYwFt
y0mpjDEExhMSRVro99MgAYwl+6LK1LexI.PVrAxhMPVrAxhMPVrAxhM+bjEa
710.xhMyzrXCAGtDGpeIu+rXC6mmrXiYP1gJK1v9oJK1bDz6iTVrgcSYwliq
Pns0XeQ7t8+86xTftho.SWRMuzNAL8TyDVLFn+rEHnj5YhkZZHQMfM2migyg
mkC3RqVZdfZbgv9YIqK3a5o+NguXXiuwGwN5TgCUuLgs4UIui3aD7fp3ioZK
0KA4XCcI4Mbyw2HnephuU2cOLbTBxgUyuT00ExJWSd91xgWv+5jvsp6OIjk3
QlYG7DGxr3RaNm1sLaOFHsaA.WC.tF.bM.3Z.lY.fqAXmA.tF.bM.3Z.v0.f
qA.WC.tF.bM.3Z.v0.fqA.WC.tF.bM.3Z.v0.fqA.WC.tF.bM.3Z.v0.fqA.
WafR6VbNgHb3UiqjBUORpRDjxkOiZfWswOsHcW2WhTfKShTJNkamh7TbeoDr
hTdeC0WI1TYmOkfxBEHVeRPYceeusjl0wKkuRMiJXNuRgf0GTTdeVKrJLTTl
hwD5NDLn2v3Xmw1Tkm0qjH47vGhWIESBU8HUtQHLD24UJobIG7JgXzifWoPG
xiRl+dk2d5X7mRuxG08cd3UxvRE3UBwnmYdkLdHBo5wpcvlGek4LUHLiIlHq
0cjvcAuxe97JkXN3UBdki17YuMuxPIF7JmedkOp667vqjSHRvqDlO6LyqjJC
c5rmRMmfv0X8M4z+zcEbJAAdk+k1qjijfWI3UNZym817JETN3UBybXz8Jax.
pdv9o8kJHNTTjkNZL9hiySvTWZb93e+.xunShtXPYzo0G1tarH7jRZMR3XvJ
7MR0I3AkgWHnQSaqQJE0YtHR3GyzIcp3xglSipkd2Gb+aFQsThYjPVSsmeqL
ZD+mIsmPwKEZ2cV3.o8r4GY1XX1j8EwaavpIWfgaLGazpUIqMXYay9c4wuFm
GmVR5KzGEO3Dh+qEM33huRXN9pUXc1v5.shYNA3P.9uA3+Ff+a.9uA3+Ff5M
.9uAnfCf+a.9uA3+Ff+a.9uA3+Ff+a.9uA3+Ff+a.9uA3+Ff+a.9uA3+Ff+a
.9uA3+Ff+a.9uA3+Ff+a.9uA3+l4.+2fDDJFwFh8Pa0kZ72ikCnTiERrnGr5
xcrK5GPo1bgD8f0OtCLkNjRsjfH8PpuCd+Y.k59xvJl8JsxdlBDNjqFLodr2
6vWaeGljVDmuK.uzyMeH6t13oBa1PSQu0Ma6sruCM432CIWV8L0aKvsQ7Fn8
SsKef51U0bzMpuxFJr8HVTaC.dT+amClKsBmk6ksKX7jLbgDubii4rbt744a
4yZN7UbndHM1kJNMhSqaU2xCVMYxSnvG4QNYxiR5g7nPSm73S6k0kGeE4QOk
tcY5ffkcojB9RohKMY4YVnCT.gzkJc.LyrCrEc5VNb5Bqdlb+R11oqufxm9l
J1zJODejGh+s05wjsIiS6Trk3xDyoY3I7RCOWQU0KeLZ0MZE8izJxGXkaqUT
pcGVa0Jy3P5WleAKQHeIxj01aT9XoU3ORqv8TqvjSZkAZRG0JpZozTAsd4ig
VQ7sGAsGZU81jROMyDRCY7kg5Oa9ISOU9XnUXe0Jbe7.q0lTSqzqGyVNhL1Z
ExGsZ5lniTNDij2xJiCsFPscUHrX3xfvB0wzNronQvxJ8YNIhdFwhhXV4mTl
zwEUe6goA36QCvggipF3SeVwGMO0Z.uBWGyUMAdUK8jvsfEjxbpocwbs9lKO
WW1HZ+1ixDPFSK.uVCs8aigVhFmFZdGHrqsCszdrJKzsJ+BgRebpIYLzR7wj
ydI92bdv3QpaqOiALYCIYca9nITOcq2PvGBW8AVdH9HO8X8FLrzFt.gMuw3r
kJ8b+LPR1VzH3yYUiOZAFBV+FryfkZavOavAlhsDal0snrnwRM9nUTHn8TMP
R2ynyg+ecfcoYsCjxhFC0f4qSNcZbxo9JO3oQd7YIVhILnjOyxfMcxC2yQP5
wBPY5kpQNxKBBj8A0yLAjnnp0Rbp7QnOAymHTrdFgxv2AmhPQzyhYriPw7IB
EqmQnryDoJBEQG1UXFuPNdQnX7AXpXCr3P7Pb5wfvDBp1fvDt1+WaSUpwaPX
FySi5zD0mQ8Tbllf9LOCp0mlXFdI9HcmvcOMTksWSnahWGKZDZrIXeeTOSi4
kf7UdlFuOhG8nmteVArxiv1jd9vfvxS+f2B2CJvrBZd42FAmNrxiAQIn997E
UmTChcjToxMq.IqrnwRWlQ+pmXeVnrUd5QDJrdJIUOpVpcTdtTrjoKhWVxXX
ZMRo3CTkvIzz5yHQyLwAOcOhFLdH9MXOqWc0yl9HKfIPjS+LnUkOF9eCxCtt
imgmn7GtEqmAmIjE0vqc5Q4OtZFkxEDFUMUfyKgPIiSmtg3QUeUclb5y0JWu
pt1Ds0.pT9tyKtkdJts4TztckjllUVLRxhsQ+t6g7Jex90jT2WsL11h73SbH
lcqYsHJe06IEwqJNj61xWeWIV3N0r0w4oGRrG6mM24+ym++QcH3as
-----------end_max5_patcher-----------
</code></pre>

danieleghisi
Site Admin
Posts: 1349
Joined: Fri Dec 03, 2010 1:25 pm

Re: Missing starting chord in chord interpolation?

Post by danieleghisi » Sat Dec 23, 2017 5:39 pm

I think the first chord is there. Only, you have a patching issue: you are interpolating between two lists with different numbers of elements, and bach.interp retains the shortest one.

If you need to interpolate between chords with different number of notes, you might also give a look at cage.chordinterp.

d

fiboribo
Posts: 21
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2016 6:17 pm

Re: Missing starting chord in chord interpolation?

Post by fiboribo » Fri Dec 29, 2017 1:49 pm

Ah yes. I suppose another solution would be to use unisons to make sure the numbers of pitches in each chord match.

Thank!

Federico

Post Reply